Article: Wednesday, 7 March 2018

Having a unique, recognisable identity is a brand’s greatest asset. Research by Elisa Maira of Rotterdam School of Management, Erasmus University (RSM) now shows that when a brand undergoes an acquisition, its identity can be undermined and it becomes less popular with consumers. Keeping the brand’s original founders on board after the acquisition can counter these negative effects, she also found.

Why some brands lose their value after an acquisition

Acquisitions are one of the most important ways companies use to grow, says researcher Maira, but they come with a lot of uncertainty. Earlier research shows that firms do not always manage to offset the extra costs of the acquisition and create extra value for the acquirer.

Even if acquisitions feature prominently in the news and are hotly debated online, there are few studies so far that look at how consumers  react to them. To reveal how and why an acquisition changes attitudes towards an acquired brand, the researcher set up a series of experiments.

For less identity relevant and more functional products, people prefer to buy products from acquired firms.

Identity relevance

In her first study, Maira showed participants a set of products and services belonging to one of two categories: products that allow consumers to express their identity – such as jewellery, hairdressing services and beers – and products that are less relevant to a person’s identity, but satisfy a functional consumer need. This latter category includes printers, washing detergents, and electric screwdrivers. Participants in the study were then asked to state whether they would prefer to buy each of these products from either an acquired firm, or a firm that had not been acquired.

Results showed that for products that are highly relevant to someone’s identity, people tend to prefer not-acquired firms. For less identity relevant and more functional products, people prefer to buy products from acquired firms. This provided Maira with the first indication that companies should take into account that acquisitions might cause ‘identity loss’ to the acquired brands, depending on the relevance of the identity that characterises the product.


But what happens when the choice is between two similar products that are both identity-relevant? Maira invited a group of participants to choose between two fictional brands of chocolate, one of which was described as acquired and the other one as not acquired. Eighty percent of participants chose to taste the brand that had not been acquired. Simply knowing about the acquisition made the chocolate from the acquired brand less attractive.

Craft beer

To verify her results outside the laboratory, Maira then moved on to analyse 2,786 comments to seven articles published on The Guardian’s website, all related to craft beers. This is a prime example of a product that is strongly connected to consumers’ identity, she says. The craft beer industry has also seen many acquisitions in recent years.

Analysis of the sentiment in the online comments showed that comments under news items that described an acquisition were decidedly more negative in their tone. This demonstrates that in the real world, acquisitions can evoke negative feelings from consumers.


A further study revealed the reason behind a more negative attitude towards acquired brands; it could be about loss of identity. Maira discovered that participants rate the identity of the same brand as less strong when they know the brand is acquired.

So, are there ways to give an acquired brand a softer landing? In another experiment, the researcher found that continuity of leadership can help to maintain consumers’ attitudes post-acquisition to pre-acquisition levels. This makes a strong case for keeping the founders of the acquired brand involved, says Maira.

More generally, acquirers should be aware that a brand’s identity is not set in stone and that the acquisition can send a strong negative signal to consumers, weakening the brand identity. Maira points out that a strong brand identity was often the very reason the firm wanted to acquire the brand in the first place.

Dr. Elisa Maira

UX Research Lead

Profile picture of Dr. Elisa Maira
Pile of books with vibrant bookmarks protruding from various pages, symbolizing in-depth research.
Header image for RSM Discovery, representing the research stories and articles section of the Rotterdam School of Management website.

RSM Discovery

RSM's Research stories in a fun and accessible format. Read the latest insights from the best researchers in the field of business. You can also subscribe to the newsletter to receive a bimonthly highlight with the most popular articles.
  • Subscribe to the newsletter

Want to learn more about this subject?

RSM offers Executive Education and Master programmes in various business areas for any stage of your career. For instance:

Last seats

Leading Change

3-day programme

Young woman posing in front of De Rotterdam, Rotterdam's iconic modern skyscraper.

Personal brand effectiveness

3-day programme

Elegant man posing in front of the Erasmus Bridge in Rotterdam

Corporate Responsibility

3-day programme

Elegant man holding a skyline of skyscrapers connected to a globe in his palm, symbolizing corporate responsibility.
Portrait of Erika Harriford-McLaren

Erika Harriford-McLaren

Corporate Communications & PR Manager

Danielle Baan

Science Communication and Media Officer

Erasmus University campus in autumn, showcasing its iconic red trees, viewed from across the campus pool.