Rotterdam school of Management, Erasmus University compact logo

Article: Thursday 19 November

Black Friday deals are hard to miss. Crossed-out prices, countdown timers and warnings that stock is running low seem to be everywhere. Perhaps you don’t need to buy anything at all, but resisting those deals can be surprisingly difficult. Before you know it, your shopping cart is full of things you never planned to buy. Why are we so sensitive to these offers and how can you make conscious buying decisions amid the Black Friday frenzy?

Dr Alexander Genevsky, associate professor of marketing at Rotterdam School of Management, Erasmus University (RSM), studies how social and emotional factors shape consumer decisions. Drawing on research in consumer psychology and neuroscience, he explains why deals are so appealing and when we are most susceptible to them. He also shares five tips for making more conscious purchasing decisions.

Why deals feel so good

A good deal can feel like a small victory, even before we have used the product we bought. That is because we value more than just the product itself: we also enjoy the feeling of having paid less than we initially expected. This satisfaction is also known as transaction utility. “A discount can make a product more appealing even when the product itself hasn’t changed,” says Genevsky.

Neuroscience adds another perspective on this process. In one study, researchers measured brain activity while people decided if they wanted to buy products or not. They found that two types of brain activity helped predict these decisions: activity in brain areas linked to anticipated rewards and activity in areas that respond to the potential costs of paying. According to Genevsky, a discount can shift the perceived balance between these two considerations, making a purchase seem more attractive. 

Retailers know how to take advantage of this. They highlight the original price to make a discount look more appealing, use countdown timers to create a sense of urgency and warn customers when stock is running low. These so-called scarcity messages about limited availability can be particularly persuasive, because they can make shoppers feel that they need to act quickly before someone else buys the product. “The excitement of getting a bargain can sometimes become more important than whether we actually need the product,” Genevsky explains.

We are particularly susceptible to offers when we are deciding quickly, distracted or mentally occupied.

How sensitive are you to deals?

Not everyone responds to discounts in the same way and responses from the same person can differ depending on the moment. According to Genevsky, we are particularly susceptible to offers when we have to make decisions quickly, are distracted or have our minds occupied with something else. For example, you might be browsing Black Friday deals on your phone while cooking at the same time. Research suggests that when our cognitive resources are limited, immediate emotional responses can have a greater influence on our choices than when we take time to think things through.

Social influences play a role too. Seeing other people buy products can further encourage impulsive purchase decisions. There are also individual differences between consumers: some people are naturally more impulsive or more responsive to promotions than others. 

Impulsive buying does not mean that every unplanned purchase is a bad decision. “The important distinction is whether the purchase reflects a genuine need or preference, or whether the promotion itself has created the desire to buy,” says Genevsky.

Why the thrill of a deal doesn’t last

The excitement of finding a deal doesn’t necessarily turn into lasting satisfaction with what we bought. “Impulse purchases can generate excitement in the moment but sometimes lead to disappointment or regret afterward,” explains Genevsky. 

What happens after the purchase can also shape our future behaviour. Research on how people look back on impulse purchases suggests that these experiences shape whether we buy impulsively again. If a product doesn’t match our needs or expectations, we may be less inclined to make similar unplanned purchases in the future. For some people, impulse buying can also lead to financial difficulties and, at times, psychological impact.

More possessions do not necessarily make us happier either. A large meta-analysis found that people with stronger materialistic values tend to report lower levels of personal well-being. Another study suggests that spending money on experiences tends to make people happier than spending money on material goods.

None of this means that buying in essence is wrong or that consumers should ignore every discount. “More conscious consumption choices can help people align their purchases with their actual needs, financial priorities and longer-term satisfaction,” says Genevsky. In other words, the aim is to make decisions based on what matters to us instead of being swept up in promotional messages and the short-lived excitement of a sale.

More conscious consumption choices can help people align their purchases with their actual needs, financial priorities and longer-term satisfaction.

Five ways to make more conscious choices

Do you want to avoid ending this Black Friday with a pile of unplanned purchases and make conscious choices instead? According to Genevsky, the most effective general approach is also the simplest: stop and think before you buy. He suggests five ways to put that into practice.

  • 1. Ask yourself where the desire came from

    Did you want this product before you saw the deal or did the discount create the desire?

  • 2. Decide before the deals arrive

    List what you actually need, set a budget and decide how much you are willing to pay before an offer reaches you. This helps you separate genuine needs from desires that are triggered by promotions.

  • 3. Think about what else you could buy with the money

    Instead of focusing on how much a discount supposedly saved, consider the alternatives. What else could you buy or do with that money? Asking yourself this question can make you think twice before clicking ‘buy’.

  • 4. Give yourself some time

    Before making an unplanned purchase, take a moment to pause. Give the initial excitement of the offer time to subside.

  • 5. Compare prices, not discounts

    Check what the product costs at different retailers instead of focusing on the advertised discount. This can help you avoid being misled by reference prices.

So when the countdown timers start ticking this Black Friday, take a moment before you click ‘buy’. The best deal might be the one you don’t need.

dr. A. (Alexander) Genevsky
Associate Professor
Rotterdam School of Management (RSM)
Erasmus University Rotterdam
Photo
Alexander Genevsky

Related articles

RSM Discovery

Want to elevate your business to the next level using the latest research? RSM Discovery is your online research platform. Read the latest insights from the best researchers in the field of business. You can also subscribe to the newsletter to receive a bimonthly highlight with the most popular articles.

Do you want to learn more about this subject?

Check out these RSM education programmes

Your contact for more information:
Danielle Baan

Science Communication and Media Officer

Erasmus University campus in autumn, showcasing its iconic red trees, viewed from across the campus pool.