Rotterdam school of Management, Erasmus University compact logo

Article: Friday, 13 March 2015

The issue of social and environmental sustainability is arguably highly relevant today, as forward-looking, self-interested companies have broadly shown they understand. Adherence to the principles underlying standards to pursue sustainability can, however, deliver unintended consequences.

Dr. Frank Wijen talking about the negative consequences of sustainability labelling

Negative consequences of sustainability labelling

How sustainable is sustainability? Some people might ask this question ironically, drawing attention to the lack of a standard definition of a word. It can mean quite different things to different people in different industry sectors and geographies, and even to people working in the same field but on opposite sides of the fence.

My recently published paper "Means versus ends in opaque institutional fields: trading off compliance and achievement in sustainability standard adoption" stresses, inter alia, that standard creators perceive a clear need to design sustainability standards in such a way that their adopters fully understand and live up to the underlying principles and rules of such standards. However, even if adopters fully comply with the standard requirements that they are being asked to meet, problems will almost inevitably arise.

Labels such as Fair Trade and Utz were created to certify that products sold in their name are produced in a socially and environmentally sustainable way. These labels certify that producers, often located on other continents, do not degrade the natural environment and significantly improve the income and working conditions of vulnerable labourers.

Producers who are anxious to achieve certification – in the expectation that they will thus be able to charge a premium price or obtain privileged access to certain markets – cannot, however, necessarily be assumed to fulfil their responsibilities. They might deliberately not live up to the duties being imposed upon them or simply not understand how to comply; whatever the reason, this failure undermines the credibility and effectiveness of the labels themselves.

…the trade-off between enforcing compliance and achieving the goals envisaged by standard creators is inherent and cannot be resolved.

Challenging problems

Such a lack of compliance is driven by opacity around the social and environmental conditions of global production chains. Opacity, in turn, has multiple causes: one, the difficulty in effectively monitoring foreign producers (entailing the risk of cosmetic compliance by adopters who wish to enjoy the benefits of compliance without bearing the costs); two, the complex interrelations of causes and consequences (leading to uncertainty among adopters as to the nature of what comprises compliant behaviour); and three, the prevalence of multiple practices (involving ambiguity among adopters as to desired practices).

To solve the opacity-related problems of uncertainty, ambiguity, and lack of incentives, standard setters can take three steps. One, creators of Fair Trade, Utz or similar certification schemes can set out rules clearly, intelligibly and unequivocally. Two, they can offer strong incentives to producers, both positive (such as price mark-ups or privileged market access) and negative (in particular, impose sanctions in cases of non-compliant behaviour). Three, standard creators can share ‘best practices’ on meeting their interpretation of sustainability, spelling out how to meet their demands.

However, universal rules do not always work as interpretations of sustainable business practices might diverge. One instance is the use of child labour. A European certificate issuer might target the elimination of child abuse in order to protect a vulnerable group and mandate a ban on child labour. However, farmers in countries like Cameroon will react with bemusement: they often view the deployment of their children in a family enterprise as akin to routine domestic chores, and therefore not abuse.

Tackling the issue is challenging, to say the least. If standard creators ignore local interpretations of sustainability, they may overshoot their goals. However, paying too much attention to idiosyncrasies might undermine the clear and universal nature of rules and, hence, adopter compliance. The more leeway that standard adopters are given to deviate from specified rules, the less likely they are to be compliant with standard requirements.

I argue that the trade-off between enforcing compliance and achieving the goals envisaged by standard creators is inherent and cannot be resolved. It can, however, be mitigated. One option is to foster a systemic mindset, in which adopters duly consider the direct and indirect relations between causes and consequences.

Another partial remedy is to stimulate the internalisation of a standard’s goals. Finally, universal ‘master standards’ that are complemented by niche standards enables adopters to adapt to context specificities. Therefore, systemically designed institutions that promote goal internalisation and duly consider context contingencies offer the potential to strike a balance between the rigidity required for substantive compliance and the flexibility to cope with the causes of opacity.

The paper’s insights hold not only for sustainability standards but also for a variety of other opaque fields in which standard setters aim to achieve certain goals (including education, financial stability, health care, traffic security, and public service). Awareness of the means-ends trade-off and application of the outlined mitigation options will enable practitioners to devise and implement reasonably effective standards.

Dr F.H. (Frank) Wijen
Former Associate Professor of Strategic Management
Rotterdam School of Management (RSM)
Erasmus University Rotterdam
Photo
Frank Wijen
Pile of books with vibrant bookmarks protruding from various pages, symbolizing in-depth research.

Related articles

RSM Discovery

Want to elevate your business to the next level using the latest research? RSM Discovery is your online research platform. Read the latest insights from the best researchers in the field of business. You can also subscribe to the newsletter to receive a bimonthly highlight with the most popular articles.

Do you want to learn more about this subject?

Check out these RSM education programmes

Global Executive MBA

Global Executive MBA

  • 21 months
  • 72,000
Digital Analytics and Customer Insights

Digital Analytics and Customer Insights

  • 16 Oct 2024
  • 3 days
  • 3,500
Essentials of Leadership

Essentials of Leadership

  • 11 Dec 2024
  • 3 days
  • 3,600
Corporate Branding

Corporate Branding

  • 3 days
  • 3,400
MScBA Master in Management

MScBA Master in Management

  • 12 months
    • €2,530 (EEA)*|
    • €22,500 (Non-EEA)
    • *see details on page
Organisational Change

Organisational Change

  • 11 Nov 2024
  • 3 days
  • 3,400
MSc Finance & Investments

MSc Finance & Investments

  • 12 months
    • €2,530 (EEA)*|
    • €22,500 (Non-EEA)
    • *see details on page
Innovation Management

Innovation Management

  • 11 Nov 2024
  • 3 days
  • 4,100
International Full-time MBA

International Full-time MBA

  • 12 months
  • 65,000
Diploma Programme in Advanced Business Valuation

Diploma Programme in Advanced Business Valuation

  • 16 Sept 2024
  • 4 - 6 months
    • €15,500 | €23,000 *
    • * see details on page
MSc International Management / CEMS

MSc International Management / CEMS

  • 18 months
    • €2,530 (EEA)*|
    • €22,500 (Non-EEA)
    • *see details on page
Strategic Account Management

Strategic Account Management

  • 6 Nov 2024
  • 3 days
  • €3,800
Finance for Communication Professionals

Finance for Communication Professionals

  • 3 days
  • 3,400
Digital Leadership and Change

Digital Leadership and Change

  • 2 Dec 2024
  • 3 days
  • 3,500
Employee Communication

Employee Communication

  • 14 May 2025
  • 3 days
  • 3,400
Leading with Decision-Driven Analytics

Leading with Decision-Driven Analytics

  • 14 Oct 2024
  • 3 days
  • 3,400
MSc Management of Innovation

MSc Management of Innovation

  • 12 months
    • €2,530 (EEA)*|
    • €22,500 (Non-EEA)
    • *see details on page
Sustainable Finance

Sustainable Finance

  • 11 Dec 2024
  • 3 days
  • 3,600
Issues Management & Public Affairs

Issues Management & Public Affairs

  • 7 Apr 2025
  • 3 days
  • 3,400
MSc Marketing Management

MSc Marketing Management

  • 12 months
    • €2,530 (EEA)*|
    • €22,500 (Non-EEA)
    • *see details on page
Winter Foundation Course in Corporate Communication

Winter Foundation Course in Corporate Communication

  • 30 Jan 2025
  • 5 days
  • 3,950
Diploma Programme in Digital Transformation

Diploma Programme in Digital Transformation

  • 23 Sept 2024
  • 6 months
  • 12,000
MScBA Accounting & Financial Management

MScBA Accounting & Financial Management

  • 12 months
    • €2,530 (EEA)*|
    • €22,500 (Non-EEA)
    • *see details on page
Beyond HR: People, Culture and Transformation

Beyond HR: People, Culture and Transformation

  • 2 Dec 2024
  • 3 days
  • 3,600
Executive MBA

Executive MBA

  • 18 months
  • 68,000
Digital and AI Strategy

Digital and AI Strategy

  • 23 Sept 2024
  • 3 days
  • 3,500
Finance for Non-Financial Managers

Finance for Non-Financial Managers

  • 21 Nov 2024
  • 2 days
  • 3,000
MSc Strategic Entrepreneurship

MSc Strategic Entrepreneurship

  • 12 months
    • €2,530 (EEA)*|
    • €22,500 (Non-EEA)
    • *see details on page
Make Strategy Work

Make Strategy Work

  • 23 Sept 2024
  • 3 days
  • 3,800
Diploma Programme in General Management

Diploma Programme in General Management

  • 14 Oct 2024
  • 1 year
    • €14,825 -
    • €15,425 depending on modules chosen *
    • * see details on the page
English Language Premaster

English Language Premaster

MSc People, Organisations & Change

MSc People, Organisations & Change

  • 12 months
    • €2,530 (EEA)*|
    • €22,500 (Non-EEA)
    • *see details on page
Leadership and Communication

Leadership and Communication

  • 3 Jun 2025
  • 3 days
  • 3,400
MSc MI Medical Business & Innovation

MSc MI Medical Business & Innovation

BSc International Business Administration (IBA)

BSc International Business Administration (IBA)

  • 3 years
    • € 2,530 (EEA)*|
    • € 11,600 (Non-EEA)
    • *see details on page
MScBA Business Analytics & Management

MScBA Business Analytics & Management

  • 12 months
    • €2,530 (EEA)*|
    • €22,500 (Non-EEA)
    • *see details on page
Leading Change

Leading Change

  • 18 Nov 2024
  • 3 days
  • 3,800
MSc Supply Chain Management

MSc Supply Chain Management

  • 12 months
    • €2,530 (EEA)*|
    • €22,500 (Non-EEA)
    • *see details on page
Crisis Communication

Crisis Communication

  • 3 days
  • 3,400
Leading the Energy Transition

Leading the Energy Transition

  • 30 Sept 2024
  • 5 days
  • 6,500
Digital Communication

Digital Communication

  • 9 Dec 2024
  • 3 days
  • 3,400
Corporate Responsibility

Corporate Responsibility

  • 18 Nov 2024
  • 3 days
  • 3,400
Women in Leadership

Women in Leadership

  • 23 Sept 2024
  • 2 days
  • 1,950
Hydrogen Training for Professionals

Hydrogen Training for Professionals

  • 12 Sept 2024
  • 2 days
  • 1,950
The Challenge of Leadership

The Challenge of Leadership

  • 19 Nov 2024
  • 4 days
  • 6,500
Project Management in Practice

Project Management in Practice

  • 2 Oct 2024
  • 3 days
  • 3,300
MSc Strategic Management

MSc Strategic Management

  • 12 months
    • €2,530 (EEA)*|
    • €22,500 (Non-EEA)
    • *see details on page
Leading with Presence

Leading with Presence

  • 21 Nov 2024
  • 2 days
  • 2,500
Digital Innovation

Digital Innovation

  • 4 Nov 2024
  • 3 days
  • 3,500
Space for Business

Space for Business

MSc Global Business & Sustainability

MSc Global Business & Sustainability

  • 12 months
    • €2,530 (EEA)*|
    • €22,500 (Non-EEA)
    • *see details on page
Reputation Management

Reputation Management

  • 10 Oct 2024
  • 4 days
  • 3,400
Design Thinking

Design Thinking

  • 16 Oct 2024
  • 6 weeks
  • 1,300
Advanced Management and Leadership Programme

Advanced Management and Leadership Programme

  • 2 Sept 2024
  • 15/16 days
  • 16,500
Storytelling for Business Success

Storytelling for Business Success

  • 2 Dec 2024
  • 2 days
  • 2,100
Finance for Senior Managers

Finance for Senior Managers

  • 3 days
  • 3,800
MSc Business Information Management

MSc Business Information Management

  • 12 months
    • €2,530 (EEA)*|
    • €22,500 (Non-EEA)
    • *see details on page
Team Leadership

Team Leadership

  • 14 Oct 2024
  • 3 days
  • 3,800
MScBA Parttime Master in Management

MScBA Parttime Master in Management

  • 2 jaar
  • 2,530
Business Valuation Workshops

Business Valuation Workshops

  • 18 Dec 2024
  • 1 day
  • 500
Strategic Communication

Strategic Communication

  • 30 Sept 2024
  • 3 days
  • 3,400
Summer Foundation Course in Corporate Communication

Summer Foundation Course in Corporate Communication

  • 16 Jun 2025
  • 4 days
  • 5,550
Effective Negotiating Skills

Effective Negotiating Skills

  • 1 Oct 2024
  • 3 days
  • 3,800
Co-creation & Stakeholder Engagement

Co-creation & Stakeholder Engagement

  • 3 days
  • 3,400

Your contact for more information:

Danielle Baan

Science Communication and Media Officer

Portrait of Erika Harriford-McLaren

Erika Harriford-McLaren

Corporate Communications & PR Manager

Erasmus University campus in autumn, showcasing its iconic red trees, viewed from across the campus pool.